bakemeawish.com Reviews
Visit websiteWe independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more ›
Don't have Amazon Prime? Students can get a free 6-Month Amazon Prime trial with free 2-day shipping, unlimited video streaming & more.
If you're not a student, there's also free 30-day trial of Prime.
Join 9,284+ users reviewing Bake Me A Wish. Read verified ratings and real customer experiences on bakemeawish.com before you order.
Related articles
3.7 / 5
Average user rating
9284
Total reviews
Why these reviews matter
We aggregate and refresh feedback continuously so you can gauge real customer experience and service quality for bakemeawish.com.
Brands may not incentivize or pay to hide reviews.
bakemeawish.com Reviews
Read real experiences from customers of bakemeawish.com.
Brands may not incentivize or pay to hide reviews.
Write a Review
Please sign in to leave a review for this product.
Crystal McNany
March 21, 2026
Birthday box
I ordered the birthday cake box for my daughter. It came today and I am excited to say everything is absolutely perfect and she loved it all. Delicious came on time perfectly packed everything is absolutely beautiful thank you so much
Jasmine Melendez
March 15, 2026
First time using this company
First time using this company. Placed an order for my disabled sister 70th birthday well in advance to ensure plenty of time for delivery. The night before the delivery date received notice it was going to be delivered 3 days later. I was beyond angry! When I called for a refund and to let them know how angry I was, just a recording. I didn’t have enough time to even order flowers. My disabled 70 year old sister received nothing from me on her birthday. So upsetting and disappointing. I finally received a refund and an excuse that it was held up by UPS. Such liars, I gave them plenty of time, They totally dropped the ball. So ANGRY! I wanted this to be my send a cake company I could use in the future. PS. Never had problems with any online companies I order food from to send as gifts. Don’t trust them!
Kristina Jonica
March 12, 2026
Cake left on floor of building entrance without any notice
Ordered a cake as a surprise "gift" for a family member one month ahead of time to allow more than enough time before the date to be delivered appropriately. Added a contact phone and message with details to contact due to it being a cake and not a random parcel. What I got was no notification, neither the recipient who I had to ask if he received the surprise bday cake to find out that nothing was delivered. It wasn't until I went back into the account information and checked tracking that I found out the cake was left on the floor of the building entrance. the only reason I am not giving this less stars is cause the cake, thankfully, looked good (even after 24h).
Ann Dean
March 12, 2026
came on time which was great as it…
came on time which was great as it arrived on my fathers birthday.
Gracie Lerma
March 3, 2026
They should not advertise next day…
They should not advertise next day shipping guaranteed I ordered Friday it’s Tuesday now and I requested morning delivery for an 80$ pie for my anniversary as a gift to my husband. It’s now an hour past the scheduled delivery window and says it’ll be here in 2-3 hours but I will be out of state by then.
Laura Matus
March 1, 2026
Great option if you are out of US and want to send a Gift
I am in Costa Rica and wanted to deliver a special birthday gift to my brother. He loved it!
Erin B
February 27, 2026
Cheesecake was delivered by 4
Cheesecake was delivered by 4, it was chilled, and the packaging was in good shape. It’s not my cake so I haven’t tried it yet but I’m sure it’s great.
Randy Burlbaugh
February 26, 2026
Delivered on time
Delivered on time
J. J.
February 21, 2026
I've been using Bake Me a Wish for my…
I've been using Bake Me a Wish for my family's celebrations for years, and I've always had great experiences with their high-quality pastries and service.
Miranda Mira Fox
February 15, 2026
Was expecting something bigger when it…
Was expecting something bigger when it comes to cookies.
Popular Searches
Best Products
Categories
© 2026 RetailCoupons.com. All rights reserved. Time Zone: Pacific Time (US & Canada).